Stay up-to-date with the politics team. Sign up for the Teen Vogue Take
You might have heard the term “constitutional crisis” thrown around on social media or in the news lately. What used to be a relatively obscure concept you might learn about in civics class is now suddenly being talked about everywhere. Some say we’re in a full-blown constitutional crisis, others claim we’re veering toward one, and others believe the panic is overblown.
Here’s what the data says: Today, a majority of Democrats and Independents agree that the United States is experiencing a constitutional crisis, while just 3 in 10 Republicans say the same, according to surveys conducted by the States United Democracy Center and YouGov.
As the leader of an organization that works to protect our democracy, and as a lawyer who served at the highest levels of state government, it’s hard to disagree with the majority of my fellow Americans as I look at what’s happening in our country right now — it feels like we are in a constitutional crisis.
But what is a constitutional crisis? Is there an on-off switch, or is it a spectrum? And, more importantly, why should you care and what can you do about it?
What is a constitutional crisis?
To answer that big question, we have to look at the source material: The United States Constitution. Our Constitution lays out a system of government that divides certain powers between the Congress, the courts, and the president, while giving states the authority to govern their people and to check the federal government.
After a series of debates and compromises, the framers of the Constitution created that system of checks and balances to prevent any one branch of government from exercising too much power. Our democracy is built to withstand our differences while safeguarding our freedoms.
You were likely taught how it’s supposed to work: The president can veto Congress’s bills. Congress can refuse to fund the president’s priorities or reject their nominees. The courts can strike down laws they deem unconstitutional. And states can defend against federal overreach.
In short, the Constitution is like a democracy rulebook. But it also relies heavily on the idea that people in power will respect those rules. An attempt to undermine or go around the system is an attack on our democracy. That’s a constitutional crisis.
How did we get here?
The Constitution puts guardrails on the president’s power — whether he likes it or not. But since President Donald Trump took office again in January 2025, the executive branch has repeatedly gone beyond its constitutional authority, testing the bounds of federal power like never before.
Most recently, in response to protests in California, Trump moved thousands of National Guard units from state control to federal service. The action came without authorization from the governor, who is typically in command. When governors need federal assistance, they ask. It should not be forced on them.
Trump has attempted to freeze federal funding for everything from disaster relief to child care. One problem: He doesn’t have that power. The Constitution gives Congress the “power of the purse” — the right to decide when and how our federal tax dollars are spent. And Congress has already promised those funds for essential services for everyday Americans.
Federal judges have repeatedly ordered the administration to cease its attempts to stop funding for essential services. But as these lawsuits wind through the courts, real people are being hurt. State and local health departments can’t pay staff, college students are having trouble accessing federal financial assistance, and job training programs are being canceled — all because of an unconstitutional power grab.
Our system is set up so that when there are constitutional disputes between the branches of government, we look to the courts to resolve them. And an overwhelming majority of Americans agree that the law should be applied equally to everyone, including those in power, according to March polling from States United and YouGov. When a court issues a ruling, it's not a suggestion — it's the law. Even the president must comply.
Imagine if a regular person, after being convicted of a violent crime in court, could decide to ignore the jury and walk free? Americans would never stand for that. Yet, the Trump administration continues to defy court orders across the country. They reportedly didn’t turn around planes carrying people being deported to El Salvador. They spent weeks refusing to comply with an order from the Supreme Court to “facilitate” the return of a Maryland resident who was wrongfully deported. And they refused to let Associated Press journalists into Oval Office events, even after a judge found that was a violation of the First Amendment. Administration officials have also made a series of concerning statements calling into question the judicial system’s check on executive power.
When it comes to the Trump administration disregarding our system of checks and balances, the list goes on. You’ve probably heard about how the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), led by Elon Musk until his recent departure, gutted federal agencies that were created by Congress. But did you know that Trump also tried to use an executive order to change key aspects of how we run elections? The Constitution is very clear that states have authority over our elections. That helps ensure that elections work for the people, not the party in power in Washington, DC. It’s how we keep our elections free, fair, and secure. Trump tried to grab that state power. Once again, a judge stopped him, blocking parts of his order.
By the way, many of Trump’s executive orders haven’t just been deemed illegal in the courts — they're also unpopular. Nearly three-quarters of Americans believe policy changes should happen through the passage of a bill in Congress, not an executive order by the president, according to our March poll with YouGov.
Are we in a crisis? And what can we do about it?
No one person gets to declare a constitutional crisis, just like no one person gets to break our democracy. And even if there were a “constitutional crisis” switch we could flip, there would be no cavalry riding to the defense of American democracy. We are the cavalry.
We can debate the wording. We can argue over what really tips us into crisis, but at the end of the day, that’s a distraction meant to divide us further. Because here’s what I’ll tell you is really important: President Trump continues to violate our constitutional system. Plain as day. He’s breaking the law and ignoring the people who are meant to keep him in check.
Despite all that, I firmly believe it’s not too late. The Trump administration has done a lot of damage in these first five months, but we can still preserve American democracy. Enforcing and upholding the Constitution is the way forward. And we need to use every power that our country’s founders gave us to do so. Because this is our democracy — our future. And the Constitution is our rulebook. It begins, “We the People,” after all.
Many of our state leaders — governors, attorneys general, and secretaries of state — are standing up for the Constitution and our freedoms, and our team at States United is committed to supporting them. Judges across the country are interpreting the law without fear or favor. But we also need citizens — especially young people — who are informed, engaged, and unafraid to speak out.
You’ve already taken the first step, which is educating yourself on how the system works. What’s next? You can vote, organize, protest, and lead. You can express your views online and challenge disinformation. You can work or volunteer for an organization that’s fighting back. You can support elected officials who defend the rule of law, hold accountable those who don’t, and one day run for office yourself.
We can’t take our democracy for granted. The Constitution doesn’t enforce itself. It relies on each of us to uphold it. The question isn’t whether we are in a constitutional crisis. It’s what we’re going to do about it.
