I walked away from my job as a writer for Senator Chuck Schumer after realizing the cost wasn’t just political fatigue — it was my values and mental health. I spent a year on Capitol Hill in 2019 crafting messages for Senate Democrats. Every day, I wrote essays that trapped me between the progressive principles I held and centrist compromises that felt like betrayals. Eventually, the disconnect between my ideals and the institution I served became impossible to ignore. Leaving my job in the Democratic Party wasn’t just a career move; it was survival.
Stay up-to-date with the politics team. Sign up for the Teen Vogue Take
In many ways, I’m not alone. Since 2019, I’ve watched young people across the country make a similar choice — turning away from a Democratic Party that once promised a “hopey, changey” vision but now feels distant, performative, and unwilling to fight for a future we deserve. Just like I reached my breaking point, many other young voters are reaching theirs, disillusioned by a party that claims to represent us, but increasingly fails to reflect our values or earn our trust on key issues.
While they’ll tell you that they have the support of young people, Democratic leaders like my former boss are increasingly alienating young voters and progressives alike due to ideological rigidity, inadequate policy responses, and a failure to address the evolving socio-political landscape.
Growing up queer and nonbinary in a small, conservative Connecticut town, I only saw one side of politics — American flags on pickup trucks, Republican campaign signs on every lawn, and a deep sense that I didn’t belong. For most of my childhood, Democrats were more of an idea than a presence, but that changed during my senior year of high school when marriage equality was legalized. For the first time, I saw a political party advocating for people like me, and I felt a glimmer of trust — that maybe, Democrats were on our side. And who was marching at the helm of the Pride Parade that year? Senator Chuck Schumer. To be clear, I believe that Schumer has supported the LGBTQ+ community meaningfully, advocating for marriage equality and supporting landmark Supreme Court cases. But over the years, that support has grown increasingly performative — rainbow in appearance but hollow in substance — fading into silence when real action is needed most.
In 2019, I helped to produce a video for Senate Democrats about Donald Trump’s transgender military service ban, interviewing trans service members and illuminating the importance of inclusive service. Today, Democrats, including Schumer, appear to be in disarray over an attempt to find a unified stance on transgender rights. What once felt like a strong display of allyship now feels ambivalent, if not outright harmful.
It’s not just Senator Schumer whose clinging to centrism has hurt real people. In a recent episode of Gavin Newsom’s podcast, “This is Gavin Newsom,” the California governor suggested that support for transgender rights had gone too far and hurt Democrats. Newsom and other Democrats owe trans folks more than vague sympathies and political calculus — our rights aren’t “too far” or “too much”; they’re non-negotiable. Defending LGBTQ+ existence should be a Democratic priority, not a liability.
In recent years, Democrats like Newsom and Schumer have embraced centrist, incremental approaches to issues that are fundamentally about humanity and dignity. That disconnect continues to push young voters away. But it doesn’t stop with trans rights. Whether it’s watered-down climate policies or half-measures on student debt and health care, the Democratic Party’s reluctance to take bold, unapologetic stances clashes with what young people expect from a so-called progressive movement. To be clear, we’re not asking for perfection — we’re demanding urgency, empathy, and courage. Instead, we’re met with compromises on core values, as if basic rights are up for negotiation. For a generation facing existential crises, that’s not leadership — it’s alienation.
Young voters have historically trusted Democrats to work against outdated policies and toward systemic change. But the shift in party dynamics has left many young voters increasingly disaffected by politics and disconnected from a party that once felt aligned with our values. Reflecting on my time on Capitol Hill, I notice this rupture more than ever.
The overall cultural disconnect and messaging failures of Senator Schumer’s Democratic Party are evident in Schumer’s recent comments on the war in Gaza. In an interview with the New York Times, Schumer’s refusal to call the crisis in Gaza a genocide wasn’t just political hedging, it was a harmful erasure of the suffering and loss experienced by Palestinians. His comments minimized a humanitarian catastrophe and sent a message that calculated language matters more than accountability or human lives. In moments of profound injustice, silence or equivocation from leaders like Senator Schumer doesn’t equate to neutrality; it enables further violence.
In contrast, alternative progressive leaders like Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have proven to have a finger on the pulse of what young progressives are feeling and recognize the indignity of our current political climate. Their advocacy for bold reform and work alongside grassroots movements like the Sunrise Movement appeals to young people because they address social justice issues directly and aggressively. Their digital strategies are solid; their teams expertly utilize social media platforms to reach young people, forging genuine connections and deepening understanding of their positioning on the issues that matter most.
But these issues — racial equity, anti-war advocacy, LGBTQ+ rights, reproductive freedom, and economic justice — are not causes that only impact or motivate young people. These struggles impact families, communities, and future generations, shaping the society we all live in. In healing these generational political divides, we can recognize our shared humanity and collective responsibility to ensure that everyone, regardless of identity or circumstance, can live freely, safely, and with opportunity. The only way to move forward is with Democratic leadership willing to adapt to these times.
I walked away from my job on Capitol Hill because it broke my heart and my trust in the Democratic Party. I left feeling disillusioned, unheard, and distressed. I know I’m not alone. When the party clings to the political center and treats urgent issues like bargaining chips, it fails to meet the moment and pushes a generation away. If Leader Schumer wants his party to retain the support of young people, we need new leadership that prioritizes people over power. We need the Democratic Party to realign its strategies and policies to reflect bold action, moral clarity, and genuine connection. This means listening, showing up, and fighting unapologetically for the future that young people (and all people) are demanding — not just during election cycles but every single day.
